Resurfacing vs Replacing a Deck: The Pros & Cons
Making the Best Choice for Your Outdoor Space
Are you deciding whether or not to replace vs resurface your deck? This guide is for homeowners to explore their options and decide what’s best for their home with confidence.
Understanding Resurfacing
Resurfacing involves repairing and refinishing the existing deck structure. This typically includes replacing worn-out or damaged deck boards, sanding down surfaces, and applying new paint or stain.
Advantages of Resurfacing
-
- Cost-effective: Resurfacing is generally less expensive than replacing an entire deck. You can save on material and labor costs.
- Time-efficient: Resurfacing can be completed quickly, often within a few days. This minimizes disruption to your daily life.
- Curb Appeal: Resurfacing can make an old deck look brand new, enhancing the visual appeal of your outdoor space.
Disadvantages of Resurfacing
-
- Limited lifespan: Resurfacing may only provide a temporary fix. If the underlying structure is rotting or damaged, issues may quickly return.
- Hidden problems: Structural issues like rot or instability may not be visible and can worsen over time, despite resurfacing.
- Maintenance: Resurfaced decks often require ongoing maintenance to preserve their appearance and structure.
Understanding Replacing
Replacing a deck involves removing the existing structure and building a new one from scratch. This is a more extensive and involved process but can offer long-term benefits.
Advantages of Replacing
-
- Longevity: A new deck can last for many years, especially if constructed with high-quality materials and craftsmanship.
- Safety: Building a new deck ensures that any underlying issues are addressed, providing a safe and stable structure.
- Customization: When replacing a deck, you can redesign the layout, choose new materials, and add features like built-in seating or lighting.
- Increase property value: A new deck can significantly enhance the value of your home, making it a worthy investment.
Disadvantages of Replacing
-
- Higher cost: Replacing a deck is more expensive than resurfacing. The costs of materials, labor, and permits can add up.
- Time-consuming: Building a new deck can take several days or even weeks, depending on the complexity of the design and weather conditions.
Factors to Consider
When deciding between resurfacing and replacing your deck, it’s essential to consider various factors, including the condition of your current deck, budget, and long-term goals.
Condition of the Existing Deck
Assess the current state of your deck. If the structure is sound and only surface-level issues are present, resurfacing may be an effective solution. However, if your deck is older than 20 years old, and the base structure is severely damaged, rotted, or unstable- it is time to replace. Remember: By keeping up with maintenance, you can expand your decks life span and structural integrity.
Budget
Evaluate your budget for the project. Resurfacing is typically less costly, making it an attractive option for those with financial constraints. If you have the funds available and seek a long-term investment, replacing the deck could be the better choice. There are also many financing options available for budget restricted projects. In the end, resurfacing may cost you more in the future with the extra repairs and long-term damage.
Long-term Goals
Consider your long-term plans for your outdoor space. If you intend to stay in your home for many years, investing in a new deck may provide lasting benefits. If you’re looking for a quick fix to improve aesthetics, resurfacing might suffice.
Conclusion
Both resurfacing and replacing a deck have their advantages and disadvantages. Resurfacing offers a cost-effective solution to enhance your deck’s appearance, whereas replacing ensures structural integrity and customization options. Overall, the main focus is the base structure and budget. By assessing the condition of your deck, budget, and long-term goals, you can make the best decision for your outdoor space.
Investing in the right option will ensure that your deck remains a beautiful and functional part of your home for years to come.
Interested in resurfacing or replacing your deck? Contact a professional fence and deck company for guidance to make the best decision for your home, family, and financial wellbeing.